Fishing in Red Dead Redemption 2 offers players a peaceful yet challenging break from the chaotic life of an outlaw. Beyond standard river species, the frontier rivers and lakes hide extraordinary Legendary Fish that test even the most experienced anglers. Mastering the locations and reeling techniques for these aquatic prize specimens is essential for completing the Fisher of Fish stranger quest and achieving full game completion.
Unlocking the Legendary Fishing Quest
Before you can begin targeting these prized aquatic creatures, you must officially activate the side mission associated with them. Visiting Jeremy Gill at his cabin along the northeastern shore of Flat Iron Lake triggers the Fisher of Fish quest line and reveals a special map. Receiving this map provides vital clues regarding where each unique species resides across the vast game world.
Equipping yourself with the correct gear is equally critical before embarking on your fishing expedition across the territories. Standard lures will fail to attract these massive creatures, requiring you to purchase Special Lake, Special River, and Special Swamp Lures from the bait shop in Lagras. Carrying all three specialized lures ensures you are properly prepared for any environment you encounter.
Prime Locations Across the Frontier
Legendary Fish are scattered throughout every major region of the map, each preferring specific aquatic environments. For instance, the Legendary Smallmouth Lake Trout can be found resting in the chilly waters of Owanjila Lake near Strawberry. Meanwhile, anglers traveling through the humid swamps of Lemoyne will find the Legendary Bullhead Catfish lurking near the murky waters surrounding the Penitentiary.
Certain species require progress through the main story before they become accessible to players. The Legendary Largemouth Bass and Legendary Redfin Pickerel reside in southern territory regions that remain off-limits during early gameplay chapters. Planning your fishing trips around story progression prevents unnecessary trips into high-risk areas.
Effective Reeling and Catching Strategies
Successfully hooking a Legendary Fish is only the first part of a demanding battle against strong underwater currents. When a fish begins struggling and splashing against the water surface, stop reeling immediately to avoid snapping your fishing line. Hold your rod steady and control line tension until the fish tires out and stops moving.
Once the fish ceases its resistance, pull up on the analog stick while reeling rapidly to pull the trophy closer to shore. Repeating this movement rhythmically allows you to haul heavy catches onto land much faster than basic reeling. Standing on stable ground near the shoreline reduces the physical distance the fish must travel when being reeled toward you.
Handling and Shipping Your Catches
After successfully landing a Legendary Fish, proper transportation is necessary to deliver your trophy to Jeremy Gill. Smaller species fit directly into Arthur's satchel, making them easy to store without burdening your mount. Larger specimens must be stowed carefully on the back of your horse for safe transport.
To complete each delivery, visit the nearest post office and mail the fresh catch directly to Mr. Gill. Dispatching your catches promptly prevents spoiled cargo and brings you one step closer to earning unique rewards and special tackle.
